A guest presents an intact driver’s license with a photo that resembles the guest; however, the license expired a month ago. What should the server/seller do?
A Ask the guest for the date of birth on the license.
B Tell the guest to recite the home address.
C Check for all other features of a valid ID.
D Refuse alcohol service.
The correct answer and explanation is :
Correct Answer: D. Refuse alcohol service.
Explanation:
When serving or selling alcohol, it is the legal responsibility of the server or seller to ensure the identification (ID) presented by a guest is valid and unexpired. Even if a driver’s license looks genuine and the photo closely resembles the guest, if the ID is expired, it is no longer considered legally valid for the purpose of alcohol sales or service.
Most state laws and alcohol regulatory agencies define a valid ID as one that is:
- Government-issued (such as a driver’s license, passport, or state ID),
- Contains a photo and date of birth,
- And is not expired.
Once an ID has expired, it technically becomes invalid. This means it cannot be legally relied upon to verify a person’s age—even if all other features appear legitimate. Continuing to serve alcohol based on an expired ID can result in significant consequences, including fines, suspension of liquor licenses, or even criminal charges for the server or business.
Why not the other options?
- A. Ask the guest for the date of birth: While this can help identify a fake ID, it does not change the fact that the ID is expired.
- B. Tell the guest to recite the home address: This checks for authenticity but still does not make the expired ID valid.
- C. Check for all other features of a valid ID: All other features may be present, but an expired ID automatically disqualifies it from being acceptable.
The only safe and legal course of action in this case is to refuse alcohol service and politely inform the guest that a current, valid ID is required. This protects both the server and the establishment from potential legal issues.